How We Rate Email Marketing Tools
Every score on MailToolFinder is placed against the written rubric below, and each tool's review gives the reason and sources for each of its five scores. We do not test tools hands-on. Scores come from public sources you can check yourself: the vendor's pricing, plan and help pages, and independent test results.
The Five Dimensions
Each tool gets a score from 1.0 to 5.0 on five dimensions. For each one, the rubric sets out what a tool must show to land in a band, and what moves it up or down within that band.
Ease of Use
20% weightHow much of the core job the intended user can do without help. For marketing and newsletter tools that user is a non-technical marketer; for transactional tools it is a developer integrating the API.
- 4.5–5.0
- Marketing tools: visual drag-and-drop editor, ready-made templates and a no-code automation builder on the entry plan, with guided setup. Developer tools: official SDKs for the major languages, copy-paste quickstarts and a sandbox or test mode.
- 4.0–4.4
- The core job is self-serve, but one piece needs more effort: a basic editor, a limited template library, or an automation builder that is form-based rather than visual. Developer tools: good docs and SDKs but no test mode.
- 3.0–3.9
- Setup needs technical steps a typical user of the tool would not expect (DNS work beyond domain authentication, self-hosting, writing templates in code), or the interface is documented as complex.
- 2.0–2.9
- Practical use needs a developer or an implementation partner for routine tasks.
- 1.0–1.9
- No self-serve path; the product is only usable through professional services.
Within a band: Breadth of ready-made templates, guided onboarding, and how much of the setup the vendor documents step by step.
Value for Money
25% weightWhat the plans cost against tools of the same type for the same capacity, using monthly-billing list prices from tools.json.
- 4.5–5.0
- Entry paid price in the cheapest quarter of its type for comparable capacity, and either a free plan that can send real campaigns or core features available on the entry plan.
- 4.0–4.4
- Entry price below the median of its type, with no major feature gated behind a tier that costs more than twice the entry plan.
- 3.0–3.9
- Priced around the median of its type, or cheap to start but with core features (automation, segmentation, removal of branding) gated to expensive tiers.
- 2.0–2.9
- Priced well above the median of its type for the same capacity.
- 1.0–1.9
- No public price; custom quotes only, with published reports of high minimum contracts.
Within a band: Free plan capacity, how steeply price rises with list size or volume, and whether core features are gated to higher tiers.
Deliverability
25% weightEvidence that mail reaches the inbox, and the tools the platform gives you to keep it there.
- 4.5–5.0
- An independent inbox placement test published in the last 24 months at 90% or above, plus custom-domain SPF, DKIM and DMARC and a dedicated IP option. A score in this band requires the test.
- 4.0–4.4
- Custom-domain authentication, a dedicated IP option and documented list hygiene or sending policy enforcement, with no recent independent test; or an independent test between 85% and 90%.
- 3.0–3.9
- Authentication supported but no dedicated IP option or reputation tooling; or an independent test between 75% and 85%.
- 2.0–2.9
- Shared infrastructure only without custom DKIM, or an independent test below 75%.
- 1.0–1.9
- Documented, unresolved deliverability problems.
Within a band: The result and recency of an independent inbox placement test, dedicated IP availability, and reputation monitoring. A test older than 24 months does not set the band; it can only place a score within it.
Without an independent placement test, deliverability is capped at 4.4. A vendor's own deliverability figure does not count as a test.
Feature Depth
15% weightHow much of the feature set expected for its type the tool covers, judged on the vendor's plan and feature pages.
- 4.5–5.0
- Covers every expected feature for its type, plus advanced ones (multi-channel, predictive or conditional logic, a full API).
- 4.0–4.4
- Covers the expected features for its type with no major gap.
- 3.0–3.9
- Missing one expected feature for its type, or several are shallow.
- 2.0–2.9
- Missing several expected features for its type.
- 1.0–1.9
- Covers only the most basic sending.
Within a band: How many of the expected features are on the entry paid plan rather than higher tiers, and integration breadth.
- Email marketing:
- visual automation builder, segmentation, A/B testing, signup forms or landing pages, ecommerce or CRM integrations, reporting, API
- All-in-one:
- visual automation builder, segmentation, A/B testing, landing pages, CRM or contact scoring, multi-channel (SMS, push or social), API
- Newsletter:
- editor built for newsletters, web archive or publication site, paid subscriptions, referral or growth tools, segmentation, API or import/export
- Transactional:
- REST API and SMTP, server-side templates, event webhooks, message logs, dedicated IP option, inbound email, suppression management
- Cold email:
- multi-step sequences, inbox rotation or multiple sending accounts, mailbox warm-up, personalization variables, reply detection, CRM integrations
Support
15% weightThe human help available on the entry paid plan, since that is the plan most readers buy.
- 4.5–5.0
- Live chat or phone on the entry paid plan, available around the clock or at least 24 hours on weekdays.
- 4.0–4.4
- Live chat or phone on the entry paid plan during business hours.
- 3.0–3.9
- Email or ticket support on the entry paid plan; chat or phone only on higher tiers.
- 2.0–2.9
- Documentation and community only on the entry paid plan; human support starts at an enterprise tier.
- 1.0–1.9
- No human support at any tier.
Within a band: Coverage hours, documentation and onboarding resources, and what higher tiers add.
The Formula
Overall = (Ease of Use × 0.20) + (Value for Money × 0.25) + (Deliverability × 0.25) + (Feature Depth × 0.15) + (Support × 0.15)
The result is rounded to one decimal place, with no adjustments or overrides. The build fails if a stored rating differs from this formula, or if a score has no reason and source behind it.
Comparison Scoring
When you compare two tools side by side, we use a separate scoring system. Each comparison criterion has a weight, and the tool that wins each criterion earns those points.
We offer four weight profiles depending on what matters most to you:
| Criterion | Default | For Creators | For Enterprise | For Budget |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | 30% | 20% | 10% | 45% |
| Deliverability | 25% | 20% | 35% | 15% |
| Overall Rating | 25% | 25% | 25% | 15% |
| Integrations | 10% | 10% | 20% | 5% |
| Free Tier | 10% | 25% | 10% | 20% |
Data Sources
Every score rests on sources a reader can open:
- + Vendor pages: pricing pages, plan comparisons, feature pages and help docs. We record the date of each tool's last check and show it next to the price, so you can see how current a figure is.
- + Web sources: when a vendor's pricing page blocks direct checks, the price comes from web search results. If we could not confirm a price, we mark it unconfirmed next to the figure on tool, pricing, comparison and calculator pages.
- + Prices by list size: where we list a price for a specific list size, we read it from the vendor's own pricing page or calculator in a browser, in the currency it shows us, and record the date. We don't fill in sizes we didn't read.
- + Independent deliverability tests: published inbox placement results from named third-party testers, with the tester and month shown next to the score.
What we don't do: sign up and test tools hands-on, or send our own deliverability tests. User review scores (G2, Capterra) are not part of the rubric. When a fact can't be confirmed from a public source, the review says so and the score stays at the low end of its band.
Affiliate Disclosure
Some links on MailToolFinder are affiliate links. If you sign up through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps fund the site.
Affiliate relationships never influence our ratings or rankings. Tools are ranked by rating, feature match, or price — not by commission rate. Several of our top-rated tools have no affiliate program at all.
Tools We Own
kalle.works Oy runs MailToolFinder and also makes EuroMail. Every page that names one of them says so.
If we list a tool we own, these rules apply on top of everything above:
- We score it with the same rubric. Its evidence comes from public pages anyone can check, not from our internal data.
- Its deliverability score stays at 4.4 or below unless a named third party has published an inbox placement test for it.
- Links to it are never affiliate links.
- Its review page does not mark up a rating for search results.
- Picks and rankings follow the same rules as for every other tool: scores, feature match or price.
No Paid Placements
No tool vendor can pay to be listed, ranked higher, or featured on MailToolFinder. Our ratings are editorial assessments based on the criteria described above.
Corrections & Feedback
If you spot an error in our data — outdated pricing, a missing feature, an incorrect deliverability figure — let us know. Accurate data is the foundation of trustworthy reviews.